But for some reason I get the error
Sorry, but there's been an error loading the Side Card extension. Please try again or contact Support.
I'm trying to display some user data here pulled from another source. Is my response data formatted correctly? For the object type itself I created a custom object type
This may be due to a slight formatting issue. I see that your endpoint returns objectId as a string instead of a number. The CRM Extensions API documentation and this similar topic indicate that 51 should be returned instead of "51".